Most of my readers know my family has done “Civil War Reenacting” for years. What began as a home school activity to teach American History has grown into a hobby that the whole family enjoys as adults now.
Changing my role (“impression” is what we reenactors call our portrayal, since we interpret history) from rifleman to civilian preacher sent by the little Presbyterian church in Madison, Florida to minister to our troops, this is to be my first “sermon.” It is inspired by a talk given by the late Dr. R.C Sproul, and is adapted for an audience of 1860’s Confederate soldiers. It is lengthy, but I think it answers a few very common questions that come up in those conversations around the campfire frequently. Enjoy!
Holiness, Justice, and Mercy
One of the most common questions raised around campfires and on those long marches that are so conducive to deep conversations is, “Why is God so different from the Old Testament to the New Testament? On the surface, the two Testaments seem so completely different from each other. In the Old Testament, God seems unduly harsh and judgmental – even capricious at times! But in the New Testament, we find Jesus apparently abrogating the death penalty for adultery, forgiving theft, etc, and being a friend to sinners. From Old Testament to New, it looks as though God radically changed, and decided to “lighten up.”
I’m hearing two popular explanations for this apparent “change” from the behavior of God in the Old Testament to His “new attitude” in the New Testament. One suggests that God decided that His old plan wasn’t working and decided to come up with an entirely new plan. The other idea suggests that God the Father is the harsh and judgmental God of the Old Testament, but that God the Son is nicer and more kind hearted, inclined towards mercy. My purpose is to show from the Scriptures that the One God of both Testaments has never changed His nature, His disposition towards sinners, nor His plan for saving sinners which was laid out before the worlds were created.
Let’s make one thing very clear right away: God the Father and God the Son, with God the Holy Spirit, are ONE God, not separate Beings. They are distinguished from one another, but not divisible, not separate. One in Essence, Three in Persons.
For God [the Father] so loved the world that He [the Father] gave His only begotten Son,
that whosoever believeth in Him shall not perish but have eternal life (John 3:16, KJV).
It is the Father who loved, and who gave. It is the Son who did the will of His Father to redeem a people from the rebellious, fallen race of Adam who are guilty of cosmic treason against their Creator! It is not that the Father is harsh and judgmental and the Son is merciful and kind. The two Persons are ONE GOD.
For as through the one man’s disobedience [Adam] the many were made sinners, even so
through the obedience of the One [Christ] the many will be made righteous (Romans
5:19, NASB).
The Bible is ONE BOOK from Genesis to Revelation, written over thousands of years on three different continents and (mostly) in two languages. The plan of God to redeem a people for Himself remains unchanged from Eden. It reached its consummation in Christ’s life of perfect obedience, His atonement, resurrection, and ascension to the right hand of God the Father. But God has always had only ONE plan of salvation.
How then can we explain the apparently huge differences between God’s seeming Old Testament harshness and His New Testament mercy? As a new Christian, I was often quite frankly offended by some of the stories I found in the Old Testament, where it seemed to me that God was being unduly harsh and judgmental. I thought, “He wouldn’t have done that in the New Testament!”
But before the worlds were created, the Three Persons of the Godhead covenanted between themselves regarding mankind, who was to fall into sin and then be rescued and restored. Theologians call this the Covenant of Redemption. It precedes the Creation, and it serves a single purpose: To show forth to all the creation the character of God: Holy, pure, and altogether righteous, yet loving and merciful to the most hideous of rebels who despised Him.
On the advice of a mentor of mine, as I read through the whole Bible, I was to note in the margin of the page next to any text which offended my sensibilities. I found quite a few in the Old Testament, where it seemed to me that God was “too quick to judge” and acted with “undue” harshness. There were passages where it also seemed, to be brutally honest, that God was being completely arbitrary and unfair! Three in particular bothered me:
- The story of Nadab and Abihu (Leviticus 10:1-3),
- The killing of Uzzah (1 Chronicles 13:1-11), and
- The extermination of the people of Canaan
Each of those notes in the margins represented a place where I disagreed with God. These were points at which God and I had very different ideas of what is right and what is fair. If I could not resolve these differences, I knew that I would simply have to accept God’s definition of what is good and bad, fair and unfair. When I disagree with God, He is right and I’m wrong! But I noted the portions anyway, if only to discover where God and I differed and also to see if those differences are truly negated in the New Testament.
Nadab and Abihu were “innocently” playing games with the fire pans and holy objects in the tabernacle when God suddenly burned them alive with fire from the altar. Their father Aaron, Moses’ brother, was offended by the deaths of his sons and appealed to Moses. But God said, “I will be treated as holy by those who come near Me (Lev 10:3).”
Was God really being unfair? Were Nadab and Abihu just innocently fooling around and then suddenly killed in an arbitrary act of a harsh God acting impulsively? Actually no. They knew what they were doing, and they knew that they were in the very presence of God. They goofed off in the presence of the LORD. They had been trained in minute detail how to properly minister in the tabernacle, yet they behaved as if God didn’t even really exist. They showed no fear of Him even as they stood before His altar. No, God was not unfair after all.
But what about Uzzah? Uzzah only tried to save the Ark of the LORD from falling into the mud from the ox-drawn cart. And what did Uzzah get for his trouble? ZAP! God kills Uzzah right on the spot. Uzzah was only trying to help, and there wasn’t exactly time to think before acting – the Ark was toppling! Surely God was unfair in this instance, right? I just had to look a little deeper to find the answer to that question. Uzzah was a Kohathite. The sole responsibility of the Kohathites was to cover and transport the holyobjects and utensils of the tabernacle (see Numbers 4:15 and 19-20). No one but the priests were allowed to even look upon the holy objects, let alone actually touch and handle them. The Kohathites were trained to approach two at a time walking backward and carrying a cover between them so that the cloth would cover the Ark. It was to be carried by men using staves inserted through rings (so placing the Ark on an oxcart was definitely a violation). The Kohathites were trained from childhood to no other vocation but the moving of the tabernacle. Every Kohathite knew better than to use an oxcart to carry the Ark – and they certainly knew better than to reach out and actually touch the Ark of God. In fact, mud would not have desecrated the Ark had it fallen – mud is not guilty of sin as men are. Uzzah treated the Ark like museum piece instead of the altar of the living God, arrogantly daring to touch it. Was God unfair and arbitrary in His response to Uzzah’s betrayal of his lifetime of training? Not at all. Uzzah actually deserved what he got.
Surely the genocide of the Canaanites by the Hebrews was unfair though, right? God ordered the Hebrews to conquer the land and kill everything that breathed Canaanite air – men, women, children, livestock, pets! That definitely seems absolutely cruel and arbitrary to a “New Testament Christian.” Why would God order the complete destruction of an entire race of people He created, and why put women and children to death?
Do not say in your heart when the LORD your God had driven them out before you, ‘Because of my righteousness the LORD has brought me in to possess this land,’ but it is because of the wickedness of these nations that the LORD is dispossessing them before you. It is not for your righteousness nor for the uprightness of your heart that you are going to possess their land, but it is because of the wickedness of these nations that the LORD is driving them out before you, in order to confirm the oath which the LORD swore to your fathers, to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. Know then, it is not because of your righteousness that the LORD your God is giving you this good land to possess, for you are a stubborn people (Deuteronomy 9:6, NASB).
So, were the Hebrews unfairly favored over the Canaanites? They weren’t given the land because they deserved it. They were given the land because God was driving out a hideously wicked people. The Canaanites received justice for their wickedness. The Hebrews, no doubt better in our estimation than the Canaanites were, nevertheless were not blessed because of their own righteousness “for you are a stubborn people,” the Lord had said. The Hebrews received MERCY. The Canaanites received JUSTICE.
When we are offended by stories in the Bible, it is often because we presume upon God’s mercy. We think that God is somehow obligated to show mercy to everyone, just because He has shown mercy to some. But if God is obligated to forgo justice and show mercy, then how can we still call it mercy? Mercy means we DON’T get what we deserve. Justice means we GET what we deserve. If mercy is mandatory, it can no longer be called mercy at all!
Jesus Christ was asked this same kind of question about the seeming unfairness of providence (see Luke 13:1-5). Where was God when the tower of Siloam fell on innocent passers-by? What about the innocent Galileans whose blood Pilate had mixed with their sacrifices? Christ’s answer was a terse as the Deuteronomy passage above:
Do you suppose that these Galileans were greater sinners than all other Galileans because they suffered this fate? I tell you, no, but unless you repent, you will all likewise perish. Or do you suppose that those eighteen on whom the tower in Siloam fell and killed them were worse debtors than the men who live in Jerusalem? I tell you, no, but unless you repent, you will all likewise perish (Luke 13:2-5, NASB).
The Galileans and victims of the Siloam tower collapse were NOT INNOCENT victims who deserved better than they got, according to Jesus. We ALL deserve what they received. NO ONE IS INNOCENT, and God is under no obligation to show mercy to anyone. The wonder is not that God shows mercy to some and justice to the rest. The wonder is that God shows mercy to anyone at all!
Only once in all of human history has an innocent man ever suffered unjustly.
If any act of God should truly offend us; if there is any Bible story where God can truly be said to have been unduly harsh and unfair, you won’t find it in the Old Testament. It’s the story of Jesus Christ. He, being the completely innocent, totally pure, sinless and perfect Man suffered and died for the wrongdoing of others – you and me. Was that unfair? Absolutely yes. Yet was God unjust? Absolutely not.
Throughout the Old Testament, Christ is pictured! He is the heel that bruises the serpent, the Passover lamb, the High Priest who intercedes for His people, the King who delivers them from evil. Christ’s work is pictured in every detail of Old Testament law, both ceremonial and civil. Christ is the culmination and fulfillment of the Old Testament! That is the main reason why the Old Testament seems harsher. Another reason is the Jews had corrupted the intent and application of the Law with their traditions. God didn’t change! His plan was never changed, altered, or improved upon from before the founding of the world.
If you want to be an effective “New Testament Christian,” you must study the Old Testament as well as the New, for it fully prefigures the gospel, demonstrating the holiness, justice, and mercy of God.